creativity vs productivy?

Sometime ago I tried a different approach of setting myself goals and deadlines for them: every week I will set weekly goals and fill up my calendar with tasks I that will get me there. The point was to not think much about what I should be doing at any given time during the week, instead, just look at the calendar and do whatever it says, being sure that that will lead me to the goals I previously set.
Planning-wise, it was great, I knew exactly what I should be doing by just looking at my calendar. I didn’t like that much that I was always feeling in a rush, like, with no time to think about what was going on. From a goal-achievement perspective…..it depends from where you see it. In terms of number of goals achieved, it increased a lot!, in terms of deadlines not met, it also increased a lot!
Let’s do some numbers to better explain what happened. Let’s say that in a regular week, I was achieving 2 goals and not achieving 1 task I wanted to get done. In a commitment week (that’s how I called those carefully planned weeks), I was achieving 5 of the set goals, and missing 5 other goals/tasks. So, the number of achieved goals increase 250% (from 2 to 5). The number of not achieved goals increased 500% (from 1 to 5). The ratio of achieved vs non-achieved remained the same: 2x (2 goals achieved per 1 non achieved). How do you think? Is is positive or not?
Besides numbers (which helps to quantify and measure things), we are humans and our perception is largely influenced by feelings and sentiments. In my case, having to deal in a regular basis with so many failures (non-achieved goals) and frustration made me question the method and eventually quit. Now I go through my weeks with one big goal that may or may not get done, trying to not get stressed when I don’t get it done.
I don’t really know what is the best approach.
- In one hand, trying to be busy and doing as much as you can will definitely increase the number of things got done (also the ones not got done). This approach aligns with what David Goggins, Tony Robbins, Elon Musk, and David Allen promote.
- In the other hand, by “surfing the week” you won’t get that much done, but you won’t miss that many either, plus is likely you will enjoy much more what you are doing. This approach is more aligned with Seth Godin, Cal Newport, and the Taoism concept of flow.
I guess every person has a natural tendency of doing this one way or the other, and trying to force doing one or the other approach is actually counter-productive. Even more, the same person may go through different states where sometimes is more aligned with one approach and sometimes with the other. Regardless pros and cons of each method, what is fundamentally true is that any of those will be better than just doing nothing. Going through life not having any expectations in regards to what goals I want to achieved? or how I’m planning to achieve them? will definitely not help us at all.