PAIN FOR WISDOM

No retreat no surrender?

Jul 9, 2024 · 3 min read

I was about 10 years old, I was playing chess with my eldest brother, who is 4 years older than me. I was doing pretty good, I managed to get two of his rooks, one of his knights and I believe one of his bishops. I still had one of my rooks, both of my bishops and knights. I was winning for sure, but I wasn’t getting too close to mate. Suddenly, my brother call the day and quit, saying “sometimes to improve you have to recognize when you lose”. More than 30 years have passed since that day and I still remember it, it is anchored into my mind and I almost think about that in a daily basis.

I do agree that is important to recognize when you are defeated, as long as we have the ability to learn from that experience. But the reason why I believe that phrase still resonate with me is because he voluntarily resigned, he didn’t wait until the very end. I could have made a mistake for example, or just simply make bad decisions during the rest of the game. But no, he resigned. That makes me wonder about something more impactful: when we start to see signs that we are not going to make it, should we resign and try again or simply go until the end, hoping those strong signals don’t translate into a defeat? (assuming we are in a scenario where we have the chance to resign and try again, like trying to set a PR).

Recently I tried to run 100 miles (link), and I had to resign at mile 52. I had an internal debate for over 15 miles, wether I should keep going or stop. Even though I was feeling pain, I could have kept going, and I’m sure my knee would have numbed at some point, and I’m sure I would have been able to put more miles (maybe finish the race?), but I’m also sure that, in that scenario, I would have hurt my knee pretty bad (after quitting, I remained pain free). Am I a looser for not having given it all? Did I make a smart decision of quitting on time to remain pain free and try again soon?

I guess the answer to those questions will reveal in the future, looking backwards, depending on what the next move is. But for the moment, I believe that the best way to understand what is going on, is to change the time span being considered. I think that “no retreat no surrender” shouldn’t be considered in the scope of a single event, but rather, in the scope of the goal to accomplish. What that means? That means that instead of considering not surrendering in the race and going to the end, even if that means hurting my knee and couldn’t run for a few months, I should consider not surrendering to my goal of running 100 miles, despite the many failed attempts I may have in that journey.

This explanation sounds great, at least in theory, but still there is something that doesn’t fit so well. For example, if I’m a boxer who is pursuing the world champion tittle, and in that journey, I’m fighting to an opponent that is clearly winning. According to my reasoning, I should quit, keep training, and try again later, because the scope is not the fight itself, but the goal of winning the belt. That is not right, I never saw a champion doing that. I can’t imagine any boxer with a champion mentality that has done something like that.

So then….what? what is the champion’s mentality? Going to the very end in every opportunity (regardless how bad things look like) or speculate what is the best thing to do at the moment thinking about the end goal? I guess the answer will reveal itself in the future….