PAIN FOR WISDOM

I simply can’t resist food temptation (cont)

Jul 15, 2024 · 7 min read

In my previous post (link) I talked about my struggle with food and how embracing pain helps me to deal with the temptation. Why I can’t claim I won the battle then? Simply put, because I don’t want to win the battle. What? That doesn’t make sense. Let’s talk about what would it take to win the battle, and then circle back on this decision.

Winning the battle

In the same way than having to exercise many times to be in shape, it is not enough to resist temptation just one day, you have to keep doing that for quite some time. Everyday the counter restarts and we start over. Doesn’t matter if I avoid eating that donut in the break room at the office yesterday, if there are more donuts today, I may need to deal with the same struggle today, and probably tomorrow. The good thing is that it gets easier. Our brain is constantly generating impulses, coming from different sources1 that we may or may not give them our attention by an action-selection process that takes place in the basal ganglia2. The selection is done according to our internal state of priorities and the value we may get from that option. By selecting one among all the competitors, we are also reinforcing its priority, having even more priority in our scale of priorities the next time a selection process takes place. So for example, if we always choose (selection process) not to workout in favor of doing other stuff and one day we go to the gym with a friend (accountability group helps a lot!), the next day, at time of the selection process, the “going to the gym” option may not be at the bottom of the scale, and if we choose to go, by virtue of an incredible willpower, next time it will rank higher, and higher. At some point, going to the gym will be part of our routine and surely won’t need any willpower from us to make that decision, it will be like auto-pilot.

What all of this means? It means that if takes an enormous willpower to resist the donut today, but we do it, then tomorrow it will take a lot of willpower to resist the temptation, but it may be a little less than today, and the same of the day after tomorrow and so on, until at some point in the future, seeing the donut won’t trigger any effect on our conscious mind because it will be “filtered” (or not selected) before our rational mind takes place. But the caveat is that even if we are not aware of that selection, it indeed exists, so if we eat a donut by random choice, it will get reinforced and the process starts over. It is not a finite game but rather an infinite game3, a daily battle to live with. I heard once a recovered alcoholic saying that “you never win the battle, is a daily struggle forever, it gets easier, but if you surrender to the temptation, even with just a drink, then you relapse and get to the starting line”. That sounded like a similar pattern of what I have to deal with in regards to food. Off course food and alcohol abuse cannot be compared directly, but the behavioral pattern of temptation seems similar to me.

Do I want to win the battle?

Now that I explained what would it take the win the battle, let’s talk about why it seems to me that I don’t want to win the battle, or at least, why I’m second doubting, which leads to not taking the actions previously described to win the battle.

First at all, let’s acknowledge the fact that I have a number of positive things to say about my weight and overall health:

  • I have very good health, I recently was assessed by an insurance company (link) and got ranked in the highest category
  • My BMI4 is where it is supposed to be
  • I don’t have to restrict myself in what I eat
  • I’m in good shape
  • My Vo2Max is around 505, for both running and cycling.
  • My max heart rate during exercise (187) is higher than my age heart rate 1806.

As you can see, my problem is not the actual weight or appearance, but rather the fact of surrendering to the temptation, something not physical but rather mentally related, and all those positive things don’t really matter when I evaluate how I feel in terms of having a strong mindset. I guess my internal assessment logic works like this : “if there is one single thing that I can’t consistently command my mind to do, then I’m not mentally strong enough”. Someone may think (I used to, actually) that that is the standard of someone with high aspirations, but now I think that that is the standard of someone weak, because truth is that even if today I feel mentally strong, in reality I’m one-single-thing away of becoming weak, it just takes one thing to completely change my perception about myself and my mindset.

Back to the original question then “do I want to win the battle?“. Why would I? I’m happy already, isn’t that our ultimate pursue in life? Why to be obsessed with this single weakness? Why should I embark in a remarkable effort to conquer this tiny issue? Until those question get answered, I guess it makes no sense to even trying right? If there is no driver for the journey, failure is guaranteed.

Can I live in peace with this temptation weakness?

I would If I wouldn’t keep asking questions to myself. If I wouldn’t ask the type of question “do I really want to eat this?” anymore, there wouldn’t be awareness of the symptom, therefore, nothing to worry about, other than just a few repetitive behavioral patterns here and there, but nothing to worry about. Unfortunately that can’t be done, revelations are coursed by the fact that once you become aware of them, it cannot be undone.

A wise person told me once that the best way to work on something related to our personality is to give it space to questions, and leave them open, as a way to anchor our subconscious mind on the topic and to listen to the clues or signals we may get, trying to decode them and correlate them to the questioning that triggered them. So I guess I will follow that approach in this case, leave the question open and be looking for hints and clues that could come up out of this. It hurst to live with open questions and unresolved situations. Every time we deal with one of those we just want to answer them, put a label and move one. I get it, I want to move on too, but I have the feeling that some situations do require more elaborated answers and solutions than others, and this is one of those.

If you kept reading until the end waiting for the silver bullet for how to deal with this problem, I’m sorry to disappoint you, but there is no silver bullet neither a magical solution that will change it all. But, as Marcus Aurelius said, “the obstacle becomes the way”7. So there you have, when there is an obstacle, there is a way.

Footnotes

  1. See my other post where I talked about the source of the signal: link. ↩

  2. Short video explaining the role of the basal ganglia in action-selection as well as other components involved in the process: link. ↩

  3. As per Simon Sinek (link) an infinite game is one with players that come and go, no end-line and rule may change over time, for which player’s strategies have to adjust. ↩

  4. BMI is an indicator of obessity for general population, considering weight and height: link. ↩

  5. VO2 max is a measure of an individual’s cardiovascular fitness: link. ↩

  6. Max heart rate is 220 – <your age>: link. ↩

  7. Meditations 5.20: link. ↩