PAIN FOR WISDOM

Have fun or have pain?

Nov 9, 2024 · 4 min read

I just signed up for a 6-hour race for this Sunday. Even though I don’t have much preparation (I have been running ~5 miles per week for the last two months), my inner desire of running ultras remains as strong as it always has been, so….game on!

During this two months I read three books (listened them actually) in my long commutes to work:

  • Born to run 2, from Christopher McDouglas
  • North, from Scot Jurek1
  • Can’t hurt me, from David Goggins2

And the very first thing that comes to my mind when thinking about the three books is the role of pain in each of them. In BtR2, the main theme is that running and the training that comes with it shouldn’t be painful, all the opposite, it should bring joy, happiness, camaraderie and be something fun. In North, Scott talks about his epic journey of a speed record in the Appalachian Trail and how he overcome pain in those long and continuous running sessions. In Can’t hurt me, David bring you to the sewer of his life and elaborates on a lifestyle around pain as the engine to get better. What a contrast!

I particularly find myself more aligned with Goggins’s mentality. I believe that in the suffering process, the things we learn stick for longer. Maybe is a survival instinct, or an evolutionary trait we developed as specie. You know what they say “easy come, easy go”, if you get something without much effort, why our body, mind and soul will spend energy trying to keep that learning around for longer time? Think about that from an optimization point of view. If getting something is easy, there is no need to keep that around for the next time you may need that, you can just learn that again next time you need it3, if that ever happens. But what took you a lot of effort to get, your body won’t discard it that easily, because in case of being needed again, you don’t want to go over that energy expenditure again.

Now, let’s talk abut the other side of things, the “having fun” philosophy from Born to run. It is true that when you are having fun and having a good time, things go smooth and usually your best yourself shows up, you are funnier, get less tired, your production rate4 is higher, and by repetition, you become better and better, kind of “effortless” right? Let’s do some numbers:

  • If you force yourself to your limit and meet pain face to face, let’s say you are at your 100% production rate and your growth rate is X.
  • If you go by the enjoyment philosophy, your production rate is, let’s say, 90%, so your growth rate will be around 90% of X.

Now, comparing the two models, the pain-based one seems to be better, if you want to be the best. But…..things get interesting when we add the repetition factor to the equation. Let ask us some questions:

  • If we repeat our pain-formula multiple times, are we expected to keep the same growth rate? Or is there any deceleration factor that must be accounted? In other words, we can guarantee to give our absolute best every day for the long term? Sure, Goggins can do that, but what about the rest of us? Some need to rest and recover, not even mention accounting for injuries.
  • In the other hand, if you are based on the “having fun formula”, can you keep doing that every day? Well, seems like yes, you can.

So in the long term, which one will prevail for the majority of people? Which one can be incorporated as a habit that you can keep doing over and over again? Regardless of this deduction, the truth is that in my personal case, if I feel I’m not giving it at all, I feel guilty, I wish I could enjoy a rest day for example, but if I don’t wake up early one day and rest to recover, I feel guilty. I don’t know if that is a “healthy” feeling, but it is what it is.

So, what is the conclusion, then? There is no conclusion, not for the moment at least. But is good to leave the question open, in the back of our minds, because hopefully, at some point the answer will reveal itself.

Footnotes

  1. The greatest ultra runner of all time ↩

  2. I read this one 3 years ago and changed my life, but this time I listened the audiobook, which also has segments in between chapters, like a podcast. ↩

  3. Even remembering things works that way. Our brain remember things that consider are important, otherwise it just discards them, as a way to optimize our energy expenditure. This is the foundational science for the “active recall” learning method that Readwise uses, for example. ↩

  4. I refer to this as the delivery of what you are doing per unit of time. It could be measure in terms of quality of quantity. For example, the amount of hours you study, the complexity of things you learn, the reps you put in, etc. ↩