Am I a lemon?

04/24/2025. When you buy a car that has a manufacturing defect, it is said that you got a lemon. When you hire someone that excels in the interviews and underperform in the actual job, is considered a lemon? Well, I recently got my first annual performance review in my 1-year-old new job and…. I’m wondering if I am a lemon.
My very first annual performance review came with a fair “underperforming” stamp on it. I’m not surprised though, I knew this was coming, one way or another, but still, it has been so long since I was in this position (more than 10 years maybe?) that I forgot how it feels. And let me tell you, even though it was kinda of expected, it really hurt. Nobody wants to be told “you are underperforming“, even when that is the absolute truth. But, we need to hear those things, because sometimes it is only after that when we hear the wake-up call.
I could recite a number of excuses to explain that scoring (and I have pretty good excuses to bring to the table), but I’m the kind of person that doesn’t make excuses. I sucked, and there is no one to blame other than me. Not only that, but I saw it coming and did nothing to prevent it. Cause and effect.
But, I’m also the kind of person that embrace pain, so, instead of feeling pity for myself, I’m taking this as an opportunity for growth, that probably would never have happened if I had gotten a normal performance review. I think that what defines us is not just the kind of results we consistently render, but also how we recover from a negative situation.
Even though all I said empowers me to go ahead, nail it and get stronger than before, there is a tiny voice that can’t be silenced, one that keeps asking : am I a lemon?, and it continues as “maybe they are realizing that I’m not as good as my resume or experience say I am, or I’m not as good as they thought I was, based on the multiple interviews they conducted before hiring me….”.
What I learned over years of falling short from my own expectations, is that the fact that that tiny voice exists is not an indicator that we are weak, fragile, self-doubted, insecure, etc., what defines how weak we are is how we react to that voice. To me, is the same as “unrealized PnL”1: if I start acting as a lemon, then yes, that will prove that I’m insecure/weak/etc. If I acknowledge the voice, use it as fuel to become better and move on, I would prove to myself that I’m beyond great, because that would mean that not only that tiny voice won’t matter, I’ll even use it to propel myself and get back to the top.
So the ultimate question is: when you have an external trigger saying you are not good at something, do you hear the echo inside and start acting/performing as you are not good at that thing? There is a big difference between “I am a failure” and “I got a bad result”. The first one speaks about a result that extrapolates to your personality, the latter just speaks about a result, not a personality trait.
Time, as usual, will reveal the path and will let me know if I’m an actual lemon (probably will get fired), or if it is just another obstacle that became part of my way2.
Footnotes
-
In finance, and particularly trading, when you buy an asset at $100 for example and then its price declines to $80, then it is said that you have an unrealized Profit and Loss of $-20. The loss doesn’t get consummated unless you sell at that price (you started with 100, and now you have 80). But if the price of the asset gets up to $120, then you have now an unrealized profit. ↩
-
This is a clear reference to stoicism and Marcus Aurelius “what stands in the way becomes the way” ↩